Stealing From The Native Hawaiians Again. (The Akaka Bill In Congress.)

The Bill

At the end of almost every Return Voyage gathering for the past three years, well-intentioned folks have asked ‘Iokepa:  “What can I do to help?”

He answers:  “When you hear that things are changing on the Hawaiian Islands–and you will–I ask that you offer a prayer for the Hawaiian people.”

There is pending now, before the United States Congress, a legislative bill, officially named, “The Native Hawaiian Government Reorganization Act of 2009″–more commonly referred to as, the “Akaka Bill.”

Return Voyage supporters across the United States have  written us:  “Finally, the Native Hawaiians will be recognized as the unique people they are–the theft of your land will be made right.”

To our many friends, allow me to clear the political fog.  The Akaka Bill–which has been bouncing around Congress since 2000, and which passed the House of Representatives a number of times, but repeatedly died on the floor of the Senate–is absolutely not the change ‘Iokepa Hanalei ‘Imaikalani had in mind.

Instead of freeing his sorely oppressed Native Hawaiians, this Akaka Bill slams the final nail into the coffin that has incarcerated the Kanaka Maoli (original people) since the arrival of the first Calvinist missionaries.  (For more, go to and click on the Historical Timeline.)

The intention of the Akaka Bill is to silence ‘Iokepa and his brethren.  The bill essentially says:  We (the government that was imposed at gunpoint) tell you (the native people who’ve inhabited these islands for 13,000 years) what you deserve.  This Congressional bill codifies the existing reality:  You accept what we offer, and you shut up.

The Background

Under this bill:  All authority remains with the original colonizers, who were, when they arrived, the Calvinist missionaries, then their sugar cane baron sons,  and then (when sugar cane ceased being profitable), they became, and remain, the real estate developing grandchildren.  Under the Akaka Bill, the transfer of  ‘Iokepa’s nation into the hands of the U.S. Interior Department insures their continuing privilege.  Those in power–either corporate or governmental–retain power.  Those disempowered (the impoverished Native Hawaiians) remain powerless.

These aboriginal people, who have for 13,000 years welcomed guests to their Islands with open arms, open hands and open hearts, are asked now to relinquish their claim to freedom.  Under the Akaka bill, they consent to become another, “Indian Tribe” minus, “Tribal” rights to pursue land claims in the courts.  It essentially legitimizes the land theft.

Still today, the grandsons and great granddaughters of the two-dozen families who overthrew the Hawaiian nation  proudly and publicly hang this framed photograph:  Their sugar cane baron ancestors holding  guns to the head of the last remaining Hawaiian monarch.

Queen Liliokalani, gun to her head, bravely held fast to her cultural values.  In her final aloha, she refused to shed her people’s blood; she was imprisoned by the men who claimed her land.  The U.S. Congress rubber-stamped the take-over of this sovereign nation.

The perpetrators made their fortunes; desecrated the land that fed a native people; outlawed Hawaiian spiritual practices.

In 1993 (on the 100th anniversary of the take-over), President Bill Clinton signed a Congressional “Apology Resolution” acknowledging the facts I’ve described, and supporting the Native claim.  At the conclusion of the signing, Senator Slade Gorton (R-Washington), said in the Congressional Record:

“…the logical consequence of this resolution would be independence.”

‘Iokepa’s people have profound spiritual gifts that can and will  inform the earth’s behavior. They are in no way, or manner, political–and that fact has been used as a knife against them. It has been in the political arena, for almost 200 years now, that the gentle, loving, beautiful Native Hawaiian people have been  disenfranchised in the name of greed.

The Confusion

The Akaka Bill is not what ‘Iokepa or his people choose.

Native Hawaiian, anthropologist J. Kehaulani Kauanui wrote in her recent book,  Hawaiian Blood.

“But the paradox for the Kanaka Maoli is that the state of Hawai’i, and arguably the U.S. government, has its own investment in seeing this political goal (the Akaka Bill) obtained because it would limit Hawaiians’ full sovereignty claim and extinguish land title–namely the kingdom, crown, and government lands–and thus settle the state’s ongoing  ‘Hawaiian problem.’

“So…the federally driven legislation threatens to amount to yet another land grab in the guise of ‘Protecting Hawaiians’.”

Politics makes strange bedfellows.  It is sometimes hard to tell your friends from your foes.

Passage of the Akaka Bill by the U.S. Senate, to date, has been withheld not by the Native Hawaiians themselves–who remain, as usual, rather powerless in this political conversation.  It has been killed by the far-right.  It has been killed by U.S. Senators who argue, ironically, that any acknowledgment of a native claim to their culturally unique identity is, “Racism.”  In other words, the very people who brought the concept of, “Racism” to this isolated Island chain (where Native Hawaiians accepted all souls without judgment), are the ones who now accuse the Native people of being, “Racist” for claiming their cultural inheritance.

And the confusion get thicker.  The Office of Hawaiian Affairs, which is a state government agency that has been assigned (by the governmental and corporate powers-that-be) the role of,  “Speaking for the Native Hawaiians” has spent millions lobbying on behalf of passage of the Akaka Bill–which would guarantee these political office-holders continued political influence.

No wonder our good friends are confused.  No wonder the media is confused.  No wonder President Barack Obama is confused.  Each absolutely believe that this legislation might bring some healing to an indigenous people who die younger, live sicker, and are most likely to be homeless, impoverished,  incarcerated.  These are all well-meaning allies of  my husband’s people who have been victimized (and baffled) by the millions spent to pass this bill–the public relations blitz, the rhetoric of fear.  (“Without Akaka, you will lose what little you have.”)

In sum:  The Native Hawaiian Government Reorganization Act of 2009 is a case of false advertising.  It is not the ticket for good–unless by that, we mean:  “The missionaries came to do good, and they did well instead.”

I ask our friends to please share this essay–and your endorsement of it–with your Senator, Congressperson, newspaper–anyone who might make a difference.  The Native Hawaiian people deserve to decide their own future.  And that can’t happen within the U.S. Department of Interior.  The Native Hawaiians are not a tribe.  They are a nation–and their nation is occupied.

This entry was posted in Ongoing Conversation With Inette Miller. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Stealing From The Native Hawaiians Again. (The Akaka Bill In Congress.)

  1. Dave Cluster says:

    My heart aches as I read and re-read this post, feelings of anger and indignation vie with an overwhelming aura of impotence and despair. What CAN be done? Is it really possible that political and corporate power and greed can be overcome or at the least be neutralized to a stalemate, so that the Kanaka Maoli be restored to equality? Can they coexist with with the current population who obviously will not want to surrender property and power? Is there any way to keep HOPE alive?
    My prayers and best wishes to you both as you begin the third journey around the continent. E-mail when you are about to hit Baltimore………………Dave

  2. admin says:

    This is absolutely not the story of hopelessness, Dave. Quite the contrary. The Kanaka Maoli have welcomed–and continue to welcome all guests to their homeland. What they ask of us is quite simple: Respect for the host culture, joined responsibility for the care of the land, the ocean, and one another. As ‘Iokepa often says: “Everything and anything can change in a breath.” That is the faith, and it is the truth, of our lives.


  3. Scott Goold says:

    Aloha ‘Iokepa and Inette ~
    Much mahalo for this clarification. Those of us who are not Kanaka Maoli – yet aware of the terrible injustice perpetrated on the indigenous people of the Hawai’ian islands – have been confused how best to respond to the proposed Akaka legislation.

    Who are we to decide the future of the Kanaka Maoli? We have needed to hear the truth from those who live aloha and truth. You both have my pledge that I will align my efforts with the Kanaka Maoli … out of respect; out of my heartfelt thanks that the Kanaka Maoli continue to share aloha, culture and open their arms to welcome us.

    You have my commitment – to the best of my ability – that I will devote my political activity to ensure that ‘Iokepa and his brethren and sisters will not be silenced. This is my prayer on behalf of the Hawai’ian people.

    Me Ke Aloha …

  4. admin says:

    Aloha Scott,
    Your solemn commitment means everything. Your words are strong, articulate and powerful. Please help circulate this essay/post to media or others who may also be in need of clarification. We remain grateful for your support.
    ‘Iokepa and Inette

  5. says:

    Regards for helping out, excellent info. “It does not do to dwell on dreams and forget to live.” by J. K. Rowling.

  6. admin says:

    You are quite welcome. Thank you for J.K.Rowling’s words as well.
    I & ‘I

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>